Jump to content
IGNORED

Semenyo


Kid in the Riot

Recommended Posts

2 minutes ago, Kid in the Riot said:

Palace interested apparently. Want him for £3m.

We want £5m.

Don't shoot the messenger ?

And, in anticipation of the "hahaha bite their hands off for £3m" posts, I don't necessarily disagree. However, word of caution: we all said the same regarding one Yannick Bolasie.

Am I the only person still not rating Yannick Bolasie then? I thought Palace got lucky that Everton paniced enough to splurge on him. I suppose if you get on the PL merry-go-round all the numbers start to look silly.

  • Like 7
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 years left on contract.  Should we look again in Jan 2022 if things not going well maybe...unless we get an absurd offer of course.

Not that I think valuation would necessarily be unfair but I dunno- we have built up some headroom now and it would be good if we used it, only selling if a great offer.

Edited by Mr Popodopolous
  • Robin 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, BCFCGav said:

I feel if we meet in the middle at 4, that’s good business by us. Almost a million a goal for this season. 

With the usual add ons . 
When a Prem club shows an interest it is nigh on impossible to refuse the player the chance to secure their future. 
So it looks like we’ve seen the last of AS in a City shirt. I had hoped we would benefit from a Bobby Reid style season from the lad next season. 
:dunno:

  • Like 3
  • Confused 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

23 minutes ago, Kid in the Riot said:

Palace interested apparently. Want him for £3m.

We want £5m.

Don't shoot the messenger ?

And, in anticipation of the "hahaha bite their hands off for £3m" posts, I don't necessarily disagree. However, word of caution: we all said the same regarding one Yannick Bolasie.

I think both clubs are in the right ball-park, he’s in that £3-5m range imho.  Few appearance based add-ons and a sell-on and I think you have to take it.

I think there are players out there that will suit Nige’s team system better.

  • Like 10
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3-5 million seems very little money for a young player with so much potential.  Having to get rid of this type of player before they’d had a chance to shine, just to fund a rebuild frustrates me especially when you look at how much we’ve wasted on our scattergun approach to buying players over the past few years. 

  • Like 13
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, Red Army 75 said:

For a young player who cost us nothing. And whilst he has potential if we sold him to palace for 4 million I wouldn’t be to disappointed. Especially seeing the next crop of youngsters coming through. 

I kinda agree, though it would be nice to keep him for another year to give the youngsters the chance and develop further. Cant see anyway the club will turn down multi million fees this summer for anyone!

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Simon bristol said:

I kinda agree, though it would be nice to keep him for another year to give the youngsters the chance and develop further. Cant see anyway the club will turn down multi million fees this summer for anyone!

It is a tricky one for the club and the two posts above yours I can relate to. The lad has potential but he hasn’t started as much lately under NP. I can see him leaving and the OP has form

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If we rate him highly we should do a Peterborough. 
Tell Palace the asking price is £10m. 
If they stump it up, great. If not, he’s stays with us and potentially increases above that value. 

  • Like 13
  • Thanks 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

47 minutes ago, Kid in the Riot said:

Palace interested apparently. Want him for £3m.

We want £5m.

Don't shoot the messenger ?

And, in anticipation of the "hahaha bite their hands off for £3m" posts, I don't necessarily disagree. However, word of caution: we all said the same regarding one Yannick Bolasie.

We didn’t ‘all’ say the same ... it amazes me how people think they can talk on behalf of every single Bristol City fan ...

Edited by BS4 on Tour...
  • Flames 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Harry said:

If we rate him highly we should do a Peterborough. 
Tell Palace the asking price is £10m. 
If they stump it up, great. If not, he’s stays with us and potentially increases above that value. 

This.

Get the idea that books need to be balanced, but not to the detriment of a lad who would be unlikely to get a game, and in 6 or 12 months could be worth a bundle.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'd take £3m cash and negotiate a 12 month loan back for next season included as part of the deal. Gives us cash and a player that we know has some ability. He'd likely be off next summer anyway with only 12 months left on his current contract.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Harry said:

If we rate him highly we should do a Peterborough. 
Tell Palace the asking price is £10m. 
If they stump it up, great. If not, he’s stays with us and potentially increases above that value. 

Not under the current coaching set up he won't. Here's to change.
I think to a degree NP has one hand tied behind his back. The budget simply isn't there to make wholesale changes to the backing staff. Our kids seem to make good progress up to first team level  then hit a brick wall. Desperately hoping this will change.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, RedEd73 said:

I'd take £3m cash and negotiate a 12 month loan back for next season included as part of the deal. Gives us cash and a player that we know has some ability. He'd likely be off next summer anyway with only 12 months left on his current contract.

Yeah, for 12 or 15 mil if he does the business whilst on 'loan' from his new club.

We would effectively sell him for peanuts, develop him further and see none of the financial benefits.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

33 minutes ago, Merrick's Marvels said:

Yes please. Goodbye, good luck. 

Not saying he won't have a career, he's just not what we need right here, right now. 

spot on.  He's got top level potential but not really top half championship ready.  Not only would it get revenue in but it would allow 2 or 3 new signings of the right age and experience at this level.

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Phillythe kid said:

Not under the current coaching set up he won't. Here's to change.
I think to a degree NP has one hand tied behind his back. The budget simply isn't there to make wholesale changes to the backing staff. Our kids seem to make good progress up to first team level  then hit a brick wall. Desperately hoping this will change.

How much do you think a second tier coach earns?

I'd probably be lucky to find a competent manager for the same sort of wedge.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I rate Semenyo. He's a great athlete - quick, strong, and powerful. He's very direct and dangerous with the ball at his feet. I think he's probably better in front of goal than many would give him credit for (any attacking player would have struggled for goals in our team this season). Given his age and the amount of potential he has, £3m - £5m seems like a pretty low fee.

The big problem is that it's hard (for me at least) to know where the market is right now following COVID. What does £5m buy you right now? Is £5m this summer the equivalent of £10m in previous years? Frankly, I have no idea - but that makes it so difficult to get an understanding of what a "good fee" might be

  • Like 6
Link to comment
Share on other sites

5m in the summer would be worth a hell of a lot considering the lack of income and the market. Yes he could easily be worth double that in 12 months time but then that 10m isn't as useful as the 3-5m would be now. 

 

Long story short I am clueless as to what to do. 

  • Like 2
  • Haha 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I can see why Palace are interested, as his despite his lack of goals, he’s quick, strong & direct.

Only 21 so still plenty of time to improve, however if we can get Palace to raise the price to £4m I’d still sell, unlike Toney, the lad isn’t a goalscorer & let’s face it, for a kid from London the possibility of playing in the Prem for a London team is going to turn his head.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3-5m probably is about right regarding him as a player rn. However why not just hang on see if he develops more next season then potentially sell him on for maybe 3/4x times that amount.
 

I’m sure the players out of contract frees up a lot of wages in regards to signing others that will suit Nige’s system. Don’t need to sell surely 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, Redrascal2 said:

I find it disappointing that after a season when he has improved so much that their are rumours we might be selling him. How does the team/squad ever improve by continuing to do this. 

See I can understand this point too. I’m really unsure on this one, especially as this season has been Semenyo’s breakthrough. 
 

He is bound to improve so I would be a little disappointed if he was to leave this soon.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 minutes ago, Finley_Smith10 said:

However why not just hang on see if he develops more next season then potentially sell him on for maybe 3/4x times that amount.

Because:

1.  He may not

2. You destroy his dreams and aspirations

3. You destroy the dreams and aspirations of every other youngster in the club and every other youngster in the world will think twice or three times before signing up. 

Edited by Hxj
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Semenyo is a lottery ticket.

He is one of the very few players we have that raises the excitement levels when he gets the ball. He is young and might become something special. No one however can know that for sure. Will he deliver that potential or become, well, a bit of a Junior Bent?

Given where we are right now, I am not sure we can take that risk. A bigger club can. It all comes down to what can we get for that kind of money in this market.

For sure it might be one of those we look back on and regret if he goes. Equally, lots of unpolished diamonds stay exactly that.

 

 

 

  • Thanks 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

21 minutes ago, BS4 on Tour... said:

We didn’t ‘all’ say the same ... it amazes me how people think they can talk on behalf of every single Bristol City fan ...

You've been a member of this forum since 2004 so I look forward to you providing the links to posts where you said Bolasie would be a £25m player after leaving us, playing for one of the biggest clubs in England.

Yours, in anticipation... 

  • Like 1
  • Haha 5
Link to comment
Share on other sites

12 minutes ago, Supersonic Robin said:

I rate Semenyo. He's a great athlete - quick, strong, and powerful. He's very direct and dangerous with the ball at his feet. I think he's probably better in front of goal than many would give him credit for (any attacking player would have struggled for goals in our team this season). Given his age and the amount of potential he has, £3m - £5m seems like a pretty low fee.

The big problem is that it's hard (for me at least) to know where the market is right now following COVID. What does £5m buy you right now? Is £5m this summer the equivalent of £10m in previous years? Frankly, I have no idea - but that makes it so difficult to get an understanding of what a "good fee" might be

You make a good point about the unknown market.  I do expect the lack of fees paid last summer and January to continue outside of the PP clubs. ⬇️⬇️⬇️

11 minutes ago, Shtanley said:

5m in the summer would be worth a hell of a lot considering the lack of income and the market. Yes he could easily be worth double that in 12 months time but then that 10m isn't as useful as the 3-5m would be now. 

 

Long story short I am clueless as to what to do. 

Could fund 5 free transfers on £20k p.w.  That will give us an advantage over some clubs we’d be competing with for the players we need to improve us.

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, Hxj said:

Because:

1.  He may not

2. You destroy his dreams and aspirations

3. You destroy the dreams and aspirations of every other youngster in the club and every other youngster in the world will think twice or three times before signing up. 

So we should become a club that underselling our ambition and accepts the first bit of interest...

Surely a young player will be more sold on, 'this club wants to go places, and we want you to be part of that journey. Not only will you get games and be in the shop window if you perform as we think you can, why move clubs on a 4 year deal worth 12k a week, when with a strong 6 months, you could move on a 4 year deal on 25k a week.... '

Link to comment
Share on other sites

48 minutes ago, Davefevs said:

I think both clubs are in the right ball-park, he’s in that £3-5m range imho.  Few appearance based add-ons and a sell-on and I think you have to take it.

I think there are players out there that will suit Nige’s team system better.

Whos negotiating this would Ashton still be in this process? It does seem around the right figure and if we can get add-ons and a sell on it would be good business.. It's how we put that money back in the team and now hopefully Pearson can add quality if this happens.

Edited by Street red
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, Kid in the Riot said:

You've been a member of this forum since 2004 so I look forward to you providing the links to posts where you said Bolasie would be a £25m player after leaving us, playing for one of the biggest clubs in England.

Yours, in anticipation... 

Have to be honest, I called Bolasie as being better than Albert. And worth more.

However, this is partly because a mutual friend of ours was less welcome at Ashton Gate at the time and never got to see him play, so I was being deliberately challenging.

  • Haha 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

13 minutes ago, Red Army 75 said:

Just don’t let him run his contract down. Diedhiou has done it and players will take notice of that . Could scare the club into reacting earlier than they want to 

He’s too young to run his contract down, as we would get compensation provided we had offered him another, a completely different scenario to Diedhiou.

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Can’t say I’d lose any sleep. Yeh, he was YPOTS,  but he didn’t exactly have any competition did he?

Lets be realistic, would he have played anywhere near as many games if we’d had a fully fit squad? Not a chance. 

Cash in. Add the mandatory sell on clause and job done. 

If we could only keep one, I’d much rather keep Liam Walsh*
 

*although I appreciate this isn’t a real scenario. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, Bristol Rob said:

Have to be honest, I called Bolasie as being better than Albert. And worth more.

However, this is partly because a mutual friend of ours was less welcome at Ashton Gate at the time and never got to see him play, so I was being deliberately challenging.

True. @Kid in the RiotI can confirm Bristol Rob called it. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I rate Semenyo and think he has potential but £5 million is a fair offer. It is a good price and there is no guarantee he will fulfil his potential. With the number of other youngsters coming through, I’d be okay with a sale. He could be the next Bolasie but he could equality be the next Ribeiro or the next Rolando Aarons...

Re Bolasie, I thought he deserved more starts and felt he’d do well at another club but certainly would never have predicted quite how well!

Edited by LondonBristolian
Link to comment
Share on other sites

We’ve got to rebuild. A major rebuild. Otherwise, the future looks bleak. 

We need to act quick, weld a team together in a couple of months. Four or five positions need strengthening with incomers that can perform consistently at Championship level.

A £4 million offer early in the window would be just fine. Personally, I’d take the £3 million. 

.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

How odd...it literally crossed my mind the other day as to who would come calling for Semenyo. 

Palace screamed at me...he is totally a Palace type player.

Semenyo literally is the biggest dilemma I've ever seen as a player for us.

He's so unatural it's confusing. 

He's big, strong, direct for his age, but has the composure of a 17 year old in front of Kylie when in front of goal. Literally watch every pass, shot or control ..tell me it isn't crisp, controlled or composed.....so, so frustrating.

Like Harry...I'd be pushing for more.

  • Haha 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, RUSSEL85 said:

A tough one. Part of me says negotiate 4m and run, but another says do another season with better coaching and see what happens.

Yep, know what’s you mean.  He’s one of those players isn’t he?  Raw, oodles of potential…..but what if this is him near peak?

I don’t think we are in a position to turn it down with a rebuild needed.

It could mean we can hold out on bids for Bentley for example, or go that extra yard to get another player over the line.

Bigger picture at play.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, spudski said:

How odd...it literally crossed my mind the other day as to who would come calling for Semenyo. 

Palace screamed at me...he is totally a Palace type player.

Semenyo literally is the biggest dilemma I've ever seen as a player for us.

He's so unatural it's confusing. 

He's big, strong, direct for his age, but has the composure of a 17 year old in front of Kylie when in front of goal. Literally watch every pass, shot or control ..tell me it isn't crisp, controlled or composed.....so, so frustrating.

Like Harry...I'd be pushing for more.

Danni was more of a “keeper” for me. ???

Link to comment
Share on other sites

27 minutes ago, GrahamC said:

I can see why Palace are interested, as his despite his lack of goals, he’s quick, strong & direct.

Only 21 so still plenty of time to improve, however if we can get Palace to raise the price to £4m I’d still sell, unlike Toney, the lad isn’t a goalscorer & let’s face it, for a kid from London the possibility of playing in the Prem for a London team is going to turn his head.

Strange one isn't he?

That goal against Millwall in the cup, i thought "wow he has the ability to do that". Plus the 5/6 assists that he got in the first half of the season.

I didn't rate him at all, based on the evidence of the 19/20 season. But i thought i would have to reevaluate my thinking around him.

However, second half of the season (like everyone else), his overall performances were not of the same standard.

His two league goals consist of 2 x chasing down the keeper, and the ball coming off his ass. He's not a natural goalscorer, in the way that Conway and Britton have demonstrated for the under 23s, and first team.

In that case, what sort of player is he?

In the current climate £4-5m affords us the capability to get 3/4 other players in to help with the rebuild.

I have no problem with him going for that figure. But a lot will depend on how we replace him.

That will be the indication of whether we've learned from our previous mistakes; and that the new processes/talent id process is working in the way we hope it will.

  • Like 4
Link to comment
Share on other sites

A really interesting one to balance. We can safely say that £5m would be very welcome this summer, and as a few have pointed out, we probably don't have too many we can realistically sell for that kind of money right now.

Personally I'd lean towards selling now, banking the cash, and reinvesting. I think we've seen the dangers of frustrating players that want to move, and running down contracts in the hope of getting "one more good season" out of a player isn't something I want to become standard.

On top of that, would that represent £0 - £5m in 4 seasons for Semenyo? Some return if so, especially considering he's had a solid, but far from spectacular season.

Edited by ExiledAjax
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, spudski said:

How odd...it literally crossed my mind the other day as to who would come calling for Semenyo. 

Palace screamed at me...he is totally a Palace type player.

Semenyo literally is the biggest dilemma I've ever seen as a player for us.

He's so unatural it's confusing. 

He's big, strong, direct for his age, but has the composure of a 17 year old in front of Kylie when in front of goal. Literally watch every pass, shot or control ..tell me it isn't crisp, controlled or composed.....so, so frustrating.

Like Harry...I'd be pushing for more.

Composure...OK, in an unimpressive season for City, the guy has most assists out of anybody... so there is some end product there.

My view is that he is a Nige type player. He likes players with pace and power. So, on  balance, I think I'd be disappointed to lose Semenyo. 

  • Like 4
Link to comment
Share on other sites

If Palace really want him they’ll pay the 5M.  Problem is they’ll let it go down to the wire, which won’t help our forward planning.  Ideally, if we let it known we’re willing to sell, we might drum up a counter offer from another club which might force Palace off the pot, earlier rather than later.

Edited by Malago
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, ncnsbcfc said:

Strange one isn't he?

That goal against Millwall in the cup, i thought "wow he has the ability to do that". Plus the 5/6 assists that he got in the first half of the season.

I didn't rate him at all, based on the evidence of the 19/20 season. But i thought i would have to reevaluate my thinking around him.

However, second half of the season (like everyone else), his overall performances were not of the same standard.

His two league goals consist of 2 x chasing down the keeper, and the ball coming off his ass. He's not a natural goalscorer, in the way that Conway and Britton have demonstrated for the under 23s, and first team.

In that case, what sort of player is he?

In the current climate £4-5m affords us the capability to get 3/4 other players in to help with the rebuild.

I have no problem with him going for that figure. But a lot will depend on how we replace him.

That will be the indication of whether we've learned from our previous mistakes; and that the new processes/talent id process is working in the way we hope it will.

I think you've hit the nail on the head re Semenyo...unless something drastically changed.

He's not a natural goal scorer, he's not a ' number 10'...is he an attacking me? Who knows...my guess is he'll have a career, but unfulfilled, because no one will work out his best position or how to play him.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, Kid in the Riot said:

Composure...OK, in an unimpressive season for City, the guy has most assists out of anybody... so there is some end product there.

My view is that he is a Nige type player. He likes players with pace and power. So, on  balance, I think I'd be disappointed to lose Semenyo. 

Hence my view in he's worth more in the market.

I can see talent...but unorthodox. So a risk.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

40 minutes ago, Hxj said:

Because:

1.  He may not

2. You destroy his dreams and aspirations

3. You destroy the dreams and aspirations of every other youngster in the club and every other youngster in the world will think twice or three times before signing up. 

I guess you have valid points. Would just like the club to maybe try hold out on this one and not act as a pushover in the market. Maybe put the price up abit to say 8-10 mill like what Peterborough did with Toney 
 

However the complete opposite to this would be if we were to get a sum of say 5 million. I saw Fevs say we could sign a number of players on eg 20k a week and strengthening the squad now is a necessity. 
 

I’m torn between the two 

Edited by Finley_Smith10
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I can understand some wanting to keep him in the hope he further improves and scores a few, probably doubling whats on the table.

But 4m or 5m right at the start of the window gives NP a chance to get some very good OOC players in, or even loan players early in the window ready for pre-season.

In that sense, 5m now could give NP a very good start to his rebuild.

If he hits it off at Palace, then decent add ons will give the club a windfall in the future.

Shame, but I think its best all round if he goes to Palace.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 minutes ago, spudski said:

He's big, strong, direct for his age, but has the composure of a 17 year old in front of Kylie when in front of goal.

:clapping:

 

He's a difficult player to judge. On one hand, he frustrates so much because he doesn't score enough (or at times look likely to), and that money could get a decent replacement, or cover the wages of a few free's. Palace aren't stupid, they know this, along with the fact that we need to rebuild and let's be fair, cash in the hand would be beneficial.

On the other hand, he is probably one of the players that is likely to go on and prove a lot of people wrong - Bobby Reid style.

We haven't looked like scoring much this season, so to knock him for not scoring enough, could be a bit unfair. Maybe with a decent pre season, and decent coaching from the right type of coach (e.g. one that is/was able to find the net regularly), he could improve ten fold.

Was there not a club supposedly interested in him recently? If there is anything substantial in both "rumours" then let the bids come in, and see where they go.

The thing with these Prem clubs, is that while people are saying "he won't get game time for ages/if at all", at that price they can afford to take the gamble. For them, it's the equivalent of us taking a "punt" on Engval. Won't miss it at all.

I'm in the undecided camp with him. Frustrates but has potential.

Agree with the Posh comments - put a high price on him and see who takes the bait. Start playing proper hardball.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If we can get £4m I would sell, providing a large sell on % is included. 

Malik Wilks (Hull) is a player we should target with some of the money. 22 years old (1 year older than Semenyo), has scored 39 goals since 2018 (for Doncaster, Barnsley and Hull). He would likely cost up to £2m, which leaves plenty in the kitty for additional incomings. 

Semenyo certainly could become a very good player, and I fully believe he would develop at a faster rate under Pearson. However, there are players out there who could have a bigger impact right away. 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...