Jump to content
IGNORED

Realistic Options


And Its Smith

Recommended Posts

All this talk of Eustace, Jones, Rowett is just making my blood boil even more. 

If they are seen as the people to take us forward then FML. 

If we were talking about bringing in someone like Potter or Kompany (if he leaves Burnley) then I could understand as that would be forward thinking. But Eustace, Jones or Rowett? Nah. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, W-S-M Seagull said:

All this talk of Eustace, Jones, Rowett is just making my blood boil even more. 

If they are seen as the people to take us forward then FML. 

If we were talking about bringing in someone like Potter or Kompany (if he leaves Burnley) then I could understand as that would be forward thinking. But Eustace, Jones or Rowett? Nah. 

In fairness, they're not quite as bad as some people are making out. Eustace was doing a good job at Birmingham. Rowett has done a decent job at Millwall.

Agree with you last point though - Pearson to Rowett (who seems the most rumoured) feels like a rather sideways move.

Pearson has been fired for being the manager of a midtable Championship club who have failed to get into the top 6 despite working on a small budget, whilst he has also received criticism (rightly or wrongly) for the style of football his team plays.

Meanwhile, Rowett has been fired for being the manager of a midtable Championship club who have failed to get into the top 6 despite working on a small budget, whilst he has also received criticism (rightly or wrongly) for the style of football his team plays.

I don't really see much logic in going from one to the other. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, Kimpton said:

I’ve stuck a 10er on Rowett so it’s win win if he becomes manager I get £90 and if he doesn’t then we don’t need to see his 352 snoozeball. I’m going to go out on a limb and say Frank Lampard please, we want to grow so let’s go big time.

Oh look another newbie. Lampard eff me sideways.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

So utterly depressing.

None of the candidates are an upgrade on Pearson.

Pearson had a respected track record with the club, knew the squad, and sticking with him came with the benefit of established popularity - and patience - from the fans, as well as being Ioved by the players. None of the bang average candidates get anywhere near justifying throwing all of that away.

Mad. Just mad.

It’s going to be messy at Ashton Gate next game. And if the new guy opens with three straight defeats without any of that established popularity to fall back on - it could be absolute carnage.

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, Kimpton said:

I would be happy with Frank Lampard brings contacts and has manager young players did ok at Derby no more but prefer him to the likes of other names mentioned.

Who wouldn't with Tomoroi, Mount etc plus excessive overspending. Still failed though didn't he.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

43 minutes ago, spudski said:

If it does turn out to be Rowett appointed, then this is a recent and decent analysis of his style of play whilst at Millwall. 

I can't see how he will be a decent fit with the players we have to hand. 

Interesting that it mentions he was released as the board were disappointed he couldn't achieve the play offs...

https://totalfootballanalysis.com/team-analysis/efl-championship-202324-millwall-tactical-analysis-tactics

For all those fans saying, big deal sacking NP, he's just an expendable coach, a new one can come in and progress the team....here is the reality.

That theory only works if you have a succession strategy, you have a vision and a plan - in terms of playing ethos and style and therefore manager. Do we have that??

Rowett appears, in footballing style terms, is very different to NP. So the squad NP has assembled doesn't on paper appear to suit Rowett's style. 

So from a squad/footballing point of view, SL could have us back at square one, with a manager (In Rowett's case with little/no record of success) who treads water for rest of season, wants a whole load of cash to rebuild in Jan/Summer and so the Lansdown cycle of stagnation goes on. 

  • Like 3
  • Flames 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, Alessandro said:

For all those fans saying, big deal sacking NP, he's just an expendable coach, a new one can come in and progress the team....here is the reality.

That theory only works if you have a succession strategy, you have a vision and a plan - in terms of playing ethos and style and therefore manager. Do we have that??

Rowett appears, in footballing style terms, is very different to NP. So the squad NP has assembled doesn't on paper appear to suit Rowett's style. 

So from a squad/footballing point of view, SL could have us back at square one, with a manager (In Rowett's case with little/no record of success) who treads water for rest of season, wants a whole load of cash to rebuild in Jan/Summer and so the Lansdown cycle of stagnation goes on. 

Exactly that 👍

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

20 minutes ago, Alessandro said:

For all those fans saying, big deal sacking NP, he's just an expendable coach, a new one can come in and progress the team....here is the reality.

That theory only works if you have a succession strategy, you have a vision and a plan - in terms of playing ethos and style and therefore manager. Do we have that??

Rowett appears, in footballing style terms, is very different to NP. So the squad NP has assembled doesn't on paper appear to suit Rowett's style. 

So from a squad/footballing point of view, SL could have us back at square one, with a manager (In Rowett's case with little/no record of success) who treads water for rest of season, wants a whole load of cash to rebuild in Jan/Summer and so the Lansdown cycle of stagnation goes on. 

I bow to the superior knowledge that the likes of yourself and @spudski and @Davefevs have when it comes to tactics and styles.

But what you describe is exactly what I’ve said a number of times both before and after yesterdays sacking: we have a terrible track record of managing any sort of transition in a way that provides continuity and consistency.

We either change everything completely. Or we seem to equate consistency with an internal appointment and all that they’ve given us is consistent disappointment.

I’m not as furious as many others over NPs departure, but I’m utterly depressed at the prospect of us making the same mistake again.

Just out of interest, do any of the three of you see anyone among the lists of potential names who’d provide us with a smoother transition? Are there others whose ethos and style would fit better with the players we’ve got? 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Still angry at the whole situation here, but now the most depressing thought is just the fact that we are now almost certainly looking at 2 to 3 years of mediocrity at best, and potentially playing god awful football depending on who comes in. Only to probably repeat the ****ing process all over again at the end of it.

All hope and optimism has just faded to be honest, I have little interest in seeing us spend a load of money just to potentially see poor football and achieve potentially less. Feeling apathetic towards City for the near to medium future now which is the worst of all.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

35 minutes ago, Alessandro said:

For all those fans saying, big deal sacking NP, he's just an expendable coach, a new one can come in and progress the team....here is the reality.

That theory only works if you have a succession strategy, you have a vision and a plan - in terms of playing ethos and style and therefore manager. Do we have that??

Rowett appears, in footballing style terms, is very different to NP. So the squad NP has assembled doesn't on paper appear to suit Rowett's style. 

So from a squad/footballing point of view, SL could have us back at square one, with a manager (In Rowett's case with little/no record of success) who treads water for rest of season, wants a whole load of cash to rebuild in Jan/Summer and so the Lansdown cycle of stagnation goes on. 

This is where we have been before .

1) Sack manager
2) New Manager doesn't want squad as doesn't fit his style
3) Buy players & increase size of squad at great cost
4) Improvement not seen or start to struggle
5) See No.1

Where those teams that SL gets all gooey over succeed, is the planning for the next man.
If they play a high press, employ a manager that uses a high press. Bringing in a manager renowned for possession football into a direct side isn't going to work.
Sadly, I doubt that Jon & Steve even consider this. 

Can't help feeling if we get the right man in and it works, it will be pure accident .

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, Nugget said:

Wouldn’t rule out Curtis getting it if he has a good start 

I absolutely would.

His family home is in the North East, he’s Nige’s appointment & we are looking elsewhere.

Might not even be in charge for a game.

No chance.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 hours ago, Med/MadHatter said:

Jon Lansdown probably thinks that he can get Claudio Ranieri in to finish off Nige's hard work for the second time, that's how deluded the crayon chewer and his Dad is!

I wouldn't be surprised if he's been tapping up Mark Robins 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 hours ago, firstdivision said:

Good joke but it’s not though, is it? All three have had some success in the Championship. Who would you go for, Pete? 

A Cardiff fan who basically refuses to acknowledge academies exist, a man who’s had one season at this level and finished below us in 17th, and a man who’s last 2 (maybe even 3) clubs have had fans chanting that the football is shit. I see none as an understandable upgrade or change on what we had. 
 

I’ve said I’d personally try out luck for Carsley at the FA. Probably get knocked back, then test the nerve of Portsmouth and Oxford for Mousinho/Manning respectively. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not that there is any love from me towards Gary Rowett (in fact I’m not arsed at all to be honest as our manager should be Nigel Pearson), but I don’t quite get the outrage from people towards him.

I’d imagine our next appointment will be much, much worse than Gary Rowett, he’s actually capable of being employed by another championship club. I expect our manager will be like Cole Skuse or something equally as mental.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, italian dave said:

I bow to the superior knowledge that the likes of yourself and @spudski and @Davefevs have when it comes to tactics and styles.

But what you describe is exactly what I’ve said a number of times both before and after yesterdays sacking: we have a terrible track record of managing any sort of transition in a way that provides continuity and consistency.

We either change everything completely. Or we seem to equate consistency with an internal appointment and all that they’ve given us is consistent disappointment.

I’m not as furious as many others over NPs departure, but I’m utterly depressed at the prospect of us making the same mistake again.

Just out of interest, do any of the three of you see anyone among the lists of potential names who’d provide us with a smoother transition? Are there others whose ethos and style would fit better with the players we’ve got? 

It’s impossible to guess how a new manager eases transition from old manager.  But Nige had made us hard to beat, instilled good defensive capabilities, so maybe Rowett.

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, italian dave said:

I bow to the superior knowledge that the likes of yourself and @spudski and @Davefevs have when it comes to tactics and styles.

But what you describe is exactly what I’ve said a number of times both before and after yesterdays sacking: we have a terrible track record of managing any sort of transition in a way that provides continuity and consistency.

We either change everything completely. Or we seem to equate consistency with an internal appointment and all that they’ve given us is consistent disappointment.

I’m not as furious as many others over NPs departure, but I’m utterly depressed at the prospect of us making the same mistake again.

Just out of interest, do any of the three of you see anyone among the lists of potential names who’d provide us with a smoother transition? Are there others whose ethos and style would fit better with the players we’ve got? 

Well we presume what will be expected from the new coach stays the same: develop youth, buy cheap and add value. Make the squad greater than the sum of it's parts. Work within tight (midtable) budgets.

Eustace and Rowett have both done some of those things, but with quite defensive/hard to beat styles of play. Eustace fired in part IIRC for the football not being exciting enough for the owners?

I really don't know - some of my best options I would say are in jobs currently. Could we poach someone like Liam Rosenior or more realistically a Steven Schumacher type? Micheal Duff widely considered an excellent coach at improving players too. 

The bigger names not in jobs I don't see working under all of those above conditions, unless SL promises them big cash to spend (change of strategy, again).

 

 

 

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Gillies Downs Leeds said:

I don't believe it will be any of the 3 that Sky said we are interested in, it will be an "up and coming" lower league coach. 

I agree...more likely to be someone like Michael Beale or Liam Manning...

Michael Beale as a No1 =

65 games, Win %age 61% 

Liam Manning Career = 

140 games, Win %age 47%

Both will be a cheaper option than most and SL will like this🤣

 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, Tomo said:

I agree...more likely to be someone like Michael Beale or Liam Manning...

Michael Beale as a No1 =

65 games, Win %age 61% 

Liam Manning Career = 

140 games, Win %age 47%

Both will be a cheaper option than most and SL will like this🤣

 

Beale won’t be cheap having been at Rangers and is full of himself.

Manning will cost compo.

I don’t think either will be cheap all-told….but that’s only my view.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

23 minutes ago, Davefevs said:

It’s impossible to guess how a new manager eases transition from old manager.  But Nige had made us hard to beat, instilled good defensive capabilities, so maybe Rowett.

 

19 minutes ago, Alessandro said:

Well we presume what will be expected from the new coach stays the same: develop youth, buy cheap and add value. Make the squad greater than the sum of it's parts. Work within tight (midtable) budgets.

Eustace and Rowett have both done some of those things, but with quite defensive/hard to beat styles of play. Eustace fired in part IIRC for the football not being exciting enough for the owners?

I really don't know - some of my best options I would say are in jobs currently. Could we poach someone like Liam Rosenior or more realistically a Steven Schumacher type? Micheal Duff widely considered an excellent coach at improving players too. 

The bigger names not in jobs I don't see working under all of those above conditions, unless SL promises them big cash to spend (change of strategy, again).

 

 

 

Thanks. William Still has been mentioned a few times as a possible left field candidate. Would he be realistic, a good fit?

  • Haha 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Kimpton said:

Eustace in to 13/8 and Rowett 5/2. Two horse race maybe, both 8/1 yesterday.

You do realise this means nothing, right? Odds are shortening simply because of where people are placing their bets. Bookies know nothing, just like us. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, LoyalRed said:

I wouldn't be surprised if he's been tapping up Mark Robins 

I'd be surprised if they didn't surreptitiously reach out to him after we played Coventry tbh, Steve's younger lookalike wouldn't be too bad in all honesty, better than blummin Rowett anyways

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

16 minutes ago, Med/MadHatter said:

I'd be surprised if they didn't surreptitiously reach out to him after we played Coventry tbh, Steve's younger lookalike wouldn't be too bad in all honesty, better than blummin Rowett anyways

And if Coventry get turned over by WBA tonight !……….👀👀👀

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Davefevs said:

Beale won’t be cheap having been at Rangers and is full of himself.

Manning will cost compo.

I don’t think either will be cheap all-told….but that’s only my view.

 

I don't think Beale will demand high wages regardless of his Rangers post....he's only been a number 1 for 65 matches in total..

Link to comment
Share on other sites

In all seriousness, what will a manager coming in be able to change? 

We still have soo many injuries and a threadbare squad, with no transfer window in sight.

I can't see this starting well atall, that combined with fan frustration... 

I still can't see the logic 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, italian dave said:

Cotterill as favourite yesterday demonstrated that better than anything I think Ive ever seen!  

Might need cotts to get us out of league 1 better than the three mentioned just means Lansdown must apologise for last time he was here

Edited by Cityboy1954
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Timing of the next appointment will be interesting - feels like this time it needs to be a quick appointment.

  • Earlier this week - they were already pretty much lined up.
  • End of week/early next week - see above or TBF to the club they've got a plan, drawn up a list and got their man quickly.
  • Anything into end of next week or week after - They had no plan and I will be worried the process not going as easily as they expected i.e targets are turning us down.

IMO the new man should be at the Sheff Wednesday game, at least watching, if not in full charge yet.

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

16 hours ago, City1984 said:

Sorry not read thread yet as only just seen news and head is spinning but thought I'd throw another unrealistic name out there (  apologies if already mentioned, as I say not had time to rad yet) 

Graham Potter 

That would see his career going like this:

Norway

Swansea/Championship 

Brighton/moving up Prem

Chelsea/Europe

Bristol City/15th Championship (but with a "nest egg")

 

I can't see it meself, but .... what do you think?

  • Haha 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Floatn Over said:

And if Coventry get turned over by WBA tonight !……….👀👀👀

I've been considering this possibility. 

Coventry are on a run of something like 1 win in 11. Lose tonight and that will be 3 losses in a row. I can't see they getting rid but that's a far worse record than Pearson was on. 

I'd personally not want him here but I could potentially see it happen.

I'm sure Tinnion and Robins must have played together? So if Tinnion is leading on recruitment then if they know each other then that could come into it.

Edited by W-S-M Seagull
Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, W-S-M Seagull said:

I've bene considering this possibility. 

Coventry are on a run of something like 1 win in 11. Lose tonight and that will be 3 losses in a row. I can't see they getting rid but that's a far worse record than Pearson was on. 

I'd personally not want him here but I could potentially see it happen.

I wouldn't rule him out. He spent a great deal of money in the summer and he hasn't been getting the results this season. Loose tonight and he could find himself out of a job in a day or so.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't agree with the sacking of Nige, quite frankly its embarrassing but dealing with the situation we're in, looking at who is out there, I'd go Eustace.

  • Played good football with Kidderminster, had some success and reached the playoffs (albeit much lower division)
  • Has experience at international level with Ireland. For some reason I like managers that get themselves out there and do this
  • Did well with Birmingham. Widely touted to finish bottom, he got them performing really well. All whilst dealing with off pitch nonsense which shows he can shut out the noise, focus on the football, connect with the players and get results. He might need that experience here if there is fallout from the sacking....
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, Moulin Rougier said:

I don't agree with the sacking of Nige, quite frankly its embarrassing but dealing with the situation we're in, looking at who is out there, I'd go Eustace.

  • Played good football with Kidderminster, had some success and reached the playoffs (albeit much lower division)
  • Has experience at international level with Ireland. For some reason I like managers that get themselves out there and do this
  • Did well with Birmingham. Widely touted to finish bottom, he got them performing really well. All whilst dealing with off pitch nonsense which shows he can shut out the noise, focus on the football, connect with the players and get results. He might need that experience here if there is fallout from the sacking....

Worth noting we also have a Irish contingent of players who will have worked with him already. Potential for Curtis Fleming to remain in position for that consistency with the players I suppose as well?

He will also know Rob Dickie from spell at QPR.

 

Edited by ollywhyte
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Having had 24hrs, or thereabouts, to digest this, it just makes less and less sense the more I think about it.  Has a sacking ever been so universally opposed by the respective fanbase...I can't think of an example.  It's the misreading of the room and tone deafness which is astounding.  I almost feel sorry for the new man, whomever he may be, because normally they are treated like a breath of fresh air to a greater or lesser extent which can then manifest into the bounce effect that you see so often.  Granted, not always, but you know what I mean.  This appointment will have to not only hit the ground running with a depleted squad etc. but also deal with the potentially toxic circumstances created by SL.

I can accept failure in sport, for the majority of teams that is the inevitable outcome in many ways, but only if you give yourselves the best chance to succeed in the first place.  Simply put, we just don't do the latter and that's what frustrates me most of all.

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Let’s just say the rumour about Pearson being told what he had to expect, (no funds out of contract players etc). going forward and basically told the board to stuff it, is true. 
 

  It will certainly show the board has lied if the next manager comes in and doesn’t get given exactly the same deal as Pearson.

  It will also show, they definitely offered terms they knew Pearson would refuse. There’s no way a new manager would accept those terms, what would be the draw or attraction for anyone coming here. 
 

 Just be honest and up front. I think fans would have preferred a straight up “we’re not able to work together” or “we’re going in a different direction” than this shambles.

 

  I can’t believe there won’t suddenly be funds available when we sign a new deal. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Will Rollason said:

I'd be interested in Ralph for sure. Hard done by at saints, got a point to prove.

Don't get me wrong, Hasenhuttl best if the 3, Marsch possibly a but hard done by in terms of Leeds but none of them feel likely do they. Would surely want a bit of money to spend too.

Still would be somewhat dismayed post NP for a while yet. Can't really enthuse for new managerial options yet.

Edited by Mr Popodopolous
Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 minutes ago, JP Hampton said:

 I can’t believe there won’t suddenly be funds available when we sign a new deal. 

It may well have been as simple as "We're not going to 're new your contract ,for reasons , and we're not giving you any players, do you want to see your contract out or we can fire you and pay you off? "

There's always money for the new guy.  

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 minutes ago, Will Rollason said:

There's always money for the new guy.  

 

 

Not especially for NP tbh!

His was a cost cutting, restraint in the market, blooding some youth, extracting value from the pick while making the side more cohesive remit.

This is how we repay him? Disgusting.

Edited by Mr Popodopolous
  • Like 4
  • Thanks 1
  • Flames 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, Mr Popodopolous said:

Don't get me wrong, Hasenhuttl best if the 3, Marsch possibly a but hard done by in terms of Leeds but none of them feel likely do they. Would surely want a bit of money to spend too.

Still would be somewhat dismayed post NP for a while yet. Can't really enthuse for new managerial options yet.

I hear you. Going to have to be the mother of all appointments because let's be honest we were all a little bit surprised that Nigel came here in the first place and seemed a great bite of businesss... much will be revealed by who we employ next. 

 

 

 

 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, Will Rollason said:

It may well have been as simple as "We're not going to 're new your contract ,for reasons , and we're not giving you any players, do you want to see your contract out or we can fire you and pay you off? "

There's always money for the new guy.  

 

 


That’s my point how can they find funds for the new guy when they couldn’t for Pearson. 
Back to my original conviction this was personal. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

19 minutes ago, LondonRobin said:

Anyone mentioned that Will Still from Ligue 1. Young but has does an impressive job so far - bit of a punt all the same. What are people’s thoughts ? Lots of opportunities for puns as well

I think the general feeling is he would be out of reach. Has Reims 5th in Ligue 1 and only 5 pts off top. Would love to see him here but, we almost certainly couldn't get him.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...